The Noble Weekly Review
Market Scorecard — Last Week
| S&P 500 | $759.97 | ▼ 0.95% |
| Nasdaq 100 | $704.40 | ▼ 2.11% |
| Dow Jones | $521.37 | ▲ 0.57% |
| Russell 2000 | $275.75 | ▲ 1.45% |
| Gold | $366.61 | ▼ 3.89% |
| Long Bonds | $81.34 | ▲ 1.80% |
| US Dollar | $28.96 | ▲ 0.10% |
Gabe's Weekly Perspective
Meta reported revenue up 26% and beat expectations, and the stock fell 9% on the week. That sentence tells you most of what you need to know about this market. The artificial intelligence story is not breaking down. The earnings keep arriving and they keep being good. What investors are punishing is what the growth costs, and in my view that is a story about interest rates far more than it is a story about artificial intelligence.
Moving Higher
| Tesla (TSLA) | $372.22 | ▲ 4.12% |
| Berkshire (BRK-B) | $542.19 | ▲ 2.30% |
| Apple (AAPL) | $347.73 | ▲ 2.04% |
Under Pressure
| Meta (META) | $642.62 | ▼ 9.13% |
| Alphabet (GOOGL) | $320.21 | ▼ 6.83% |
| Nvidia (NVDA) | $210.96 | ▼ 3.27% |
| Amazon (AMZN) | $248.00 | ▼ 2.84% |
| JPMorgan (JPM) | $331.58 | ▼ 2.25% |
| Microsoft (MSFT) | $524.51 | ▼ 0.79% |
What Moved Markets Last Week
Meta Beat Expectations and Fell 9% Anyway
Meta reported third quarter results on Wednesday. Revenue came in at $64.6 billion, up 26.1% from a year earlier, ahead of what analysts expected. By Thursday the stock was down roughly 7% in a single session, about $124 billion of market value, and it finished the week down 9.13%. The Nasdaq Composite fell 2.6% that day, its worst day since June, and semiconductor stocks fell about 7%.
The problem was not the business. It was the spending. Meta's free cash flow turned negative, the company raised the floor of its planned capital spending to a range of $135 to $145 billion, and it announced a new class of non voting shares to help pay for it. Investors looked at a company growing revenue 26% and decided the cost of that growth was the more important number.
The Earnings Keep Winning
Here is the part I think gets lost. Every time the market has questioned whether artificial intelligence is real, the earnings have answered. Revenue growth keeps showing up. Demand keeps showing up. That has been true quarter after quarter, and it was true again this week even as the stock fell.
What is genuinely in question is not whether these companies can generate business from this technology. It is whether the enormous amounts they are spending to build it will pay off, and how long investors are willing to wait to find out. Those are different questions, and conflating them leads people to sell a good business because they do not like a line on the cash flow statement.
This Is a Rate Story More Than an AI Story
Why does the spending bother people so much right now? Because money is expensive. When borrowing costs are high, every dollar of capital investment gets scrutinized harder and the market demands to see the return sooner. The clearest illustration is in the smaller players: CoreWeave recently saw its bonds trade at a yield around 14.5%, which is what it costs a company in that position to raise money today.
Now imagine the same spending plans against meaningfully lower interest rates. The arithmetic changes. Heavy investment that reads as reckless at today's borrowing costs starts to read as building for the future when money is cheaper. My view, and I have been saying this for a few weeks, is that rates are headed lower, and that when they do move the market will look at these same capital spending numbers very differently. Last week was another step in that direction. Long term Treasury bonds rose 1.80%, their second consecutive weekly gain.
Markets Do Not Move in Straight Lines
I want to be careful here, because connecting those two ideas can sound like a promise that falling rates will lift these stocks tomorrow. It does not work that way. Rates came down last week and technology stocks still fell, because the flight to safety is also real and both things happen at once. Money moving into bonds is money moving out of something else.
These adjustments play out over quarters, not over trading sessions. You will see weeks where the interest rate picture improves and your growth holdings drop anyway. That is normal and it is not evidence that the thinking is wrong. Patience is the actual skill here, and it is the hardest one to practice when the screen is red.
The Weak Get Culled and the Strong Get Stronger
The sharpest version of this is happening in what the industry calls neoclouds, companies that buy graphics processors and rent out computing power. Over the weekend Elon Musk said that debt markets have largely stopped lending to firms without meaningful revenue outside of artificial intelligence data centers, predicted that the more than 200 companies in this category face what he called guppy level death and consolidation, and said SpaceX would not be buying any of them. Those stocks fell further on Monday. CoreWeave is down roughly 38% this month and the research firm Gartner has forecast that more than 80% of neoclouds will no longer operate independently by 2030.
Read Musk's reasoning closely though, because it is the whole point. He said SpaceX was able to raise $40 billion of debt for processors precisely because it is investment grade and has real revenue from Starlink and launch services. That is not an argument that artificial intelligence is finished. It is an argument that balance sheets matter. Companies with real earnings and access to cheap capital will fund this buildout and come out the other side. Companies without those things will not. Difficult stretches like this one separate the two, and that separation is healthy even when it is unpleasant to watch.
This Week Tells Us More
We get a much clearer picture in the next few days. Microsoft and Alphabet both report Wednesday after the close, and Amazon reports Thursday. All three are spending heavily on this buildout, which makes them the real test of whether the pattern holds. It is worth noting that Alphabet fell 6.83% last week without having reported anything at all. The market marked it down in sympathy with Meta, on the assumption it would tell a similar story. Wednesday we find out whether that assumption was right.
What This Means for Your Portfolio
Last week I wrote that you should change your mind when the facts change and hold steady when only the mood changes. Meta's cash flow statement is a fact, not a mood, and I am taking it seriously. My read is that it reflects the price of money today rather than a broken business, and that lower rates will change how this spending is judged. I could be wrong about that. If rates stay high for longer than I expect, or if these investments take considerably more time to produce returns than the companies suggest, then this adjustment has further to run.
What I would not do is sell good businesses in the middle of the week they report 26% revenue growth. The rest of the market, meanwhile, quietly had a decent week. The Dow rose 0.57%, smaller companies gained 1.45%, and bonds rose again. A diversified portfolio did its job. If you would like to talk through what you own and how it is positioned for what comes next, now is a sensible time.
On the Radar — October 26 – 30
- Tuesday, October 27
PayPal (PYPL) earnings — before the open(Est. EPS: $1.34) - Tuesday, October 27
SoFi Technologies (SOFI) earnings — before the open(Est. EPS: $0.17) - Tuesday, October 27
Visa (V) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $3.50) - Wednesday, October 28
Alphabet (GOOGL) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $3.11) - Wednesday, October 28
Microsoft (MSFT) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $4.82) - Wednesday, October 28
ServiceNow (NOW) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $1.03) - Thursday, October 29
Amazon (AMZN) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $2.00) - Thursday, October 29
Coinbase (COIN) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $-0.16) - Thursday, October 29
Intel (INTC) earnings — after the close(Est. EPS: $0.40) - Thursday, October 29
Mastercard (MA) earnings — before the open(Est. EPS: $5.32)
Market price and performance data sourced from Yahoo Finance. Earnings estimates sourced from Finnhub. Data reflects closing prices for the period indicated and may be subject to revision.
Content in this material is for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. All performance referenced is historical and is no guarantee of future results. All indices are unmanaged and may not be invested into directly. Securities and Advisory services offered through LPL Financial, A Registered Investment Advisor, Member FINRA/SIPC.